News › Celtic

Celtic board will orchestrate Martin O'Neill's exit, panel claims

The Football Show panel says Martin O'Neill has been let down by a Celtic board lacking strategy, but insists his standing among the club's greats is safe.

By Peter Martin,

Martin O'Neill has been "left exposed by a club with no strategy", according to the panel on The Football Show, who believe Celtic will now engineer his departure.

The panel set out the problems they see around the manager: players he did not want, players being used out of position, a number of unhappy players in the squad, and accusations that Shaun Maloney and Mark Fotheringham were picking the team.

The panel argued that the issue is not that O'Neill's legacy is being tarnished. "He's being exposed to a situation where he hasn't got the players he wanted," it was said. "They've left him wide open to a group of players who can't do what he wants them to do at particular levels."

Training ground claims

On the suggestion that others were running the team, the panel pointed back to O'Neill's first spell at Celtic, from 2000 to 2005, when he did not really take training either. That was not an issue at the time, they said, because he kept the overview while his coaches handled the day-to-day work. "Lots of managers don't take training," the panel added.

They were critical of those now dismissing him, noting that O'Neill is a two-time European Cup winner who played under one of the greatest managers in British football history, with a managerial record at Wycombe, Leicester City and Celtic. "So to suddenly degrade him and say that he doesn't have a clue is an embarrassment on a number of people's part."

The blame, in the panel's view, lies with a recruitment policy O'Neill has had no control over, leaving him with inferior players and a downgraded club.

Departure and legacy

"What they will do is they will orchestrate his departure," the panel said. Even so, they expect history to be kind to O'Neill, predicting he will be seen as "one of the top three managers in Celtic football club history". "And this little debacle at the moment will not derail people's overall view."

Verdict on the board

The panel gave the Celtic board credit for presiding over 20 years of dominance and for running the club well commercially, saying "it's unarguable as a business they've had some of the best boards to run it as a business".

On ambition, long-term strategy and recruitment, however, they said the board is wide open to criticism, and predicted that many will record that "this board is the most disliked board".

Watch the full episode of The Football Show

Latest Celtic news