Dunfermline's thrift meets Morton's goals at both ends
Dunfermline arrive unbeaten and stingy, Morton high-scoring but leaky. The three clubs both have played show the contrast, and why the hosts get the nod.
By Barrie Moran,
Both sides have been collecting results lately, and they have gone about it in almost opposite ways. That is the short version of Saturday's Championship meeting at KDM Group East End Park. The clearest way to see the difference is through the three clubs both have played in their last five.
Same opponents, different afternoons
Dunfermline and Greenock Morton have each faced Partick Thistle, Queen's Park and Stenhousemuir recently. Dunfermline took two wins and a draw from those games, scoring three and conceding one. Morton won all three, scoring nine and conceding five.
Stenhousemuir is the result that tells the story. Dunfermline went there and won 1-0. Morton had them at home and won 4-3. Both took the points, but one of those afternoons was a good deal calmer than the other. Partick Thistle follows the same pattern: a 1-1 draw at East End Park for Dunfermline, a 3-2 away win for Morton.
Dunfermline: unbeaten and hard to score against
Dunfermline are unbeaten in five, with three wins and two draws. They have scored eight, conceded two and kept three clean sheets. Their most recent outing was a goalless draw at Raith Rovers.
A word of caution on the scoring, though. Five of those goals came in one afternoon, the 5-1 win over Inverness. Around it sit 1-0 wins at Stenhousemuir and Queen's Park, a 1-1 with Partick Thistle and the 0-0 at Raith. This is a side that wins by being hard to beat rather than by running riot, and the Inverness result looks like the exception rather than the rule. Only Inverness and Partick Thistle have scored against them in that run.
Morton: four wins, then Livingston
On paper Morton's form is the better of the two: four wins and a defeat. The wins came first, 2-1 at Arbroath, 2-0 against Queen's Park, 3-2 at Partick Thistle and 4-3 against Stenhousemuir. Then came a 2-0 defeat at Livingston last Saturday. They have scored eleven and conceded eight, and their only clean sheet came against Queen's Park.
Morton score freely, but they give chances back. Livingston was the one game in five where they failed to score, and it cost them. On its own, a single defeat is not a trend, but it does show what happens when the goals at their end dry up and the leaks at the other do not.
The one previous meeting
These sides met on 19 September, with Morton at home, and Dunfermline won 1-0. One match is thin evidence and I would not lean hard on it. Still, a single-goal win with a clean sheet is exactly the kind of result Dunfermline have been producing since.
The verdict
My view is that Dunfermline do not lose this, and I lean towards a home win by the narrow sort of margin they have been dealing in. Morton's best results have come in open games with goals at both ends. Dunfermline have spent the last five weeks making sure their games are not like that.
What would change my mind is Morton getting the game opened up. Their record says they are comfortable in a scrap where both sides score, and Dunfermline have shown little evidence of how they cope with one. It is also worth saying the sample is modest: five games apiece and a single meeting. I hold the view, but I hold it loosely.