Journos panel says SFA should not sack Pocognoli after six games
Peter Martin, Hugh MacDonald and Gordon Parks say Sebastien Pocognoli deserves more time after the 4-0 against Switzerland, but his mistakes must be pointed out.
By Peter Martin,
On The Journos, Peter Martin, Hugh MacDonald and Gordon Parks considered whether the SFA should sack Sebastien Pocognoli after the 4-0 result against Switzerland. Their answer was not yet. "I don't think they should sack him", the panel said, but they added that somebody has to point out the mistakes.
The discussion took in Steve Clarke and Oli McBurnie, and the argument that "Managers are not magicians". The panel also made the case against dropping the core of the side: McTominay, Ferguson and McGinn. Reflecting on the Switzerland game, the panel said: "I just knew the pain was coming".
Youth development and the Scottish player
The panel noted that 38 of the 132 players across six Premiership games were Scots. They also discussed five clubs blocking Craig Mulholland's youth proposals, under the line "The needs of the few dominate our game". Falling grassroots participation came up, and Dundee, Falkirk and Motherwell were named as clubs doing it right.
Aberdeen and Mario Frick
On Aberdeen, the question was whether Mario Frick is the club's biggest gamble. "What a gamble." The panel pointed to a 6.2 million pound loss and to no continuity from Stephen Glass to Jimmy Thelin. Kilmarnock v Aberdeen on Saturday was billed as the only place to be this weekend.
The Celtic AGM
The panel asked whether Dermot and Ross Desmond will attend the Celtic AGM, and discussed the takeover panel, the supporters' questions, whether there will be a five-year plan, and whether pent-up fury will explode at the meeting. They also raised one fan group's line that Desmond "has the same relationship with the fans that a dog has with a lamp post".
Ralph Brand and Tony Mowbray
The episode paid tribute to Ralph Brand, who has died aged 89, and to the early-60s Rangers side he played in alongside Jimmy Millar and Jim Baxter. The panel described Millar as the steel and Brand as the silk, and asked whether that was the best Rangers team ever. The panel also sent best wishes to Tony Mowbray and discussed why Celtic did not fit him.