Alloa's August rout of Montrose now looks a long time ago
Montrose host an Alloa Athletic side on four straight defeats. The form, the shared opponents and the one previous meeting, plus a verdict.
By Barrie Moran,
The last time these two met, on 15 August, Alloa Athletic won 3-0 at home and Montrose went back up the road with nothing. It is the only meeting between them this season, and three months on it reads like a result from a different Alloa.
Alloa's form has gone the wrong way
Alloa arrive at Links Park on four straight defeats. Queen of the South won 1-0 at their place, Peterhead beat them 2-1, Airdrieonians won 3-2 in a game where Alloa at least scored twice, and last Saturday East Kilbride put four past them in a 4-1. Ten conceded in five matches is the figure that matters, and they have let in goals in every one of those four defeats. The one win in the run, 3-0 at East Fife on 17 October, now looks like the exception rather than the rule.
Montrose are hardly flying either
Montrose's last five read L L D W D, with six scored and seven conceded. The worry is the most recent end of that run: a 2-1 home defeat to East Fife, then a 3-0 loss at Cove Rangers, the only one of the five in which they failed to score. Before that, draws at East Kilbride and Hamilton Academical and a 3-0 home win over Peterhead suggested a side that was hard to beat. A fortnight has undone some of that impression, though not all of it.
What the shared opponents say
Both sides have played East Fife, East Kilbride and Peterhead in this run, and the results pull in opposite directions.
- East Fife: beat Montrose 2-1 at Links Park, lost 3-0 at home to Alloa.
- East Kilbride: drew 1-1 with Montrose, beat Alloa 4-1.
- Peterhead: lost 3-0 at Montrose, beat Alloa 2-1.
Across those three games Montrose scored five and conceded three. Alloa scored five and conceded six. The scoring is level. The gap is at the other end, and it is the same story the wider form tells. Alloa can find goals, but they are giving away too many to be trusted at the moment.
The verdict
I make Montrose the likelier winners at Links Park on Saturday at 17:30. They have the better recent record, they are at home, and they face a side that has conceded in each of its last four outings. Their own two defeats on the bounce stop me going further than a narrow lean, and a draw would not surprise me.
What would change my mind is the Alloa that turned up in August and at East Fife. Both of those were 3-0 wins, and the second came against the side that has just won at Links Park. If that version of Alloa reappears, the view goes out the window. But one previous meeting is thin evidence, and the five most recent games for each club point the other way.