News › Airdrieonians

East Fife v Airdrieonians: tight margins meet a leaky record

East Fife bring three straight wins and a mean defence into Saturday's meeting with Airdrieonians at Bayview. Here's what the form says, and where it doesn't agree.

By Barrie Moran,

East Fife have won their last three, and none of those wins was by more than two goals. Peterhead were beaten 1-0 at Bayview last weekend, Montrose 2-1 away the week before, and Queen of the South 2-0 at home before that. It isn't spectacular, but it is a side that has worked out how to keep the door shut. Both of their clean sheets in the last five came in that run.

Airdrieonians arrive on a better note than they managed in October, with two wins on the bounce: 2-0 at home to Queen of the South and a 3-2 win away at Alloa Athletic. Before that, though, came three defeats in a row, and one of them was a 4-0 hammering at Ross County. Airdrie have let in 9 in their last five to East Fife's 6, and that gap is mostly Dingwall.

The Alloa problem

The detail that complicates the neat version of this preview is Alloa Athletic. They came to Bayview on 17 October and won 3-0, which is the heaviest defeat on East Fife's recent record. Airdrie went to Alloa three weeks later and scored three. Over the three opponents both sides have faced, Airdrie come out ahead: two wins and a defeat, 6 scored and 4 conceded, against East Fife's one win and two defeats, 3 scored and 5 conceded.

The rest of that comparison is close to identical. Both beat Queen of the South 2-0 at home. Both lost to Hamilton Academical by a single goal, East Fife 2-1 away and Airdrie 2-1 at home. So the whole difference between them on shared opponents comes down to one club, and how each side fared against it.

The last meeting

These two drew 0-0 at Airdrie on 29 August. That is the only meeting this season, and one goalless draw in late summer tells you very little about either side now. It does at least suggest neither found the other easy to break down, which fits with East Fife's recent habit of narrow margins.

Verdict

I lean towards East Fife, narrowly. They are at home, they are in the better run of form, and their recent wins have come with very little conceded. Airdrie's defensive record over the same stretch is plainly worse, and the side that lost 4-0 at Ross County and 1-0 at home to Cove Rangers wasn't long ago.

The evidence is thin, though, and it doesn't all point the same way. East Fife's run came against Peterhead, Montrose and Queen of the South. Their two defeats came against Hamilton and Alloa, the stronger-looking sides on this list. Airdrie's win at Alloa is the best single result either club has to show. If that performance reflects where Airdrie are now, rather than the October slump, the Alloa comparison is the better guide and I'd be wrong.

A low-scoring game looks the likeliest shape, given the August draw and East Fife's recent margins. My view is a narrow home win, with a draw the obvious alternative. That's a view, not a forecast.

Latest Airdrieonians news