Hearts' wild swings meet Dundee FC's narrow margins at Dens Park
Dundee FC and Hearts arrive with identical records over five matches, but the way each got there points to very different afternoons.
By Harvey Watkins,
The figure that reshapes this fixture is a range, not a result. Hearts arrive at Dens Park having conceded 14 goals in their last five matches, yet two of those five ended in clean sheets. Their recent run includes a 5-0 win over St. Mirren and a 2-0 win at Motherwell, alongside a 7-1 defeat at Celtic and a 5-2 home loss to Falkirk. On recent evidence, Hearts can look like very different sides from one week to the next. That makes Saturday's 17:45 kick-off harder to read than the two clubs' matching records suggest.
Same record, different routes
Dundee FC and Hearts have both won two, drawn one and lost two of their last five. The paths could hardly be more different. Dundee's matches have been tight. None in that run was decided by more than two goals, and they have scored in every one of them. They have scored 9 and conceded 8, and they have not kept a clean sheet. Their most recent outing was a 2-1 defeat at St. Johnstone on 7 November, which followed a 3-1 home win over Kilmarnock.
Hearts have scored 12 and conceded 14, and the spread of those goals is the story. When they have been good, they have been emphatic. When they have been poor, the scorelines have run away from them. Their last match was the 5-2 home defeat by Falkirk on 8 November, which came after a 2-2 draw with Rangers.
What the shared opponents show
Both clubs have recently played Falkirk, Rangers and St. Mirren, and the comparison is revealing. Both drew 2-2 with Rangers. Against Falkirk, Dundee won 2-1 away while Hearts lost 5-2 at home. Against St. Mirren, the picture flips: Dundee lost 2-1 away, while Hearts won 5-0 at home.
Across those three matches Dundee scored 5 and conceded 5. Hearts scored 9 and conceded 7. That fits the wider pattern of Dundee producing close games and Hearts producing extremes. It is only three matches, though, and the venues differ, so it is a hint rather than a verdict.
The only recent meeting
The most recent meeting between the sides was on 6 September 2026, when Hearts won 2-1 at home. A single one-goal result offers little to build on, other than confirming that Dundee found the net, as they have done in each of their last five matches.
How it might go
Dundee have no clean sheets in their last five, and Hearts have shipped heavy defeats twice in the same period. My view is that goals at both ends look more likely than not. Dundee's recent results suggest a close contest, and a draw or a one-goal margin would sit comfortably with how their matches have been going.
Hearts are the harder side to predict. Their best recent performances would put them ahead of anything Dundee have shown, and their worst would leave the door wide open. Which version turns up is likely to decide this, and the recent record gives no reliable way of knowing in advance.
What PLZ members are predicting
Nine PLZ Soccer members have entered this fixture in the PLZ Predictor. Of those, 44 per cent have gone for a draw, 33 per cent for a Dundee FC win and 22 per cent for a Hearts win. The most commonly predicted score is 2-2, picked by three members. It is a small group, and these are members' own picks rather than any guide to the result.