Inverness v Ayr United: identical form, very different defences
Inverness and Ayr United arrive with matching five-game records, but the detail separates them. Form, shared opponents, the September meeting and a verdict.
By Barrie Moran,
Lay the last five results for Inverness and Ayr United side by side and the totals match exactly: two wins, a draw, two defeats, eight goals scored and nine conceded. It would be easy to call Friday night at the Caledonian Stadium a coin toss and leave it there. The detail says otherwise, and the place to start is the clean sheets column. Inverness have kept two. Ayr have kept none.
Same numbers, different shapes
The Inverness run splits cleanly in two. In mid-October they beat Arbroath 2-0 at home and won 2-0 at Raith Rovers without conceding. Since then the defence has come apart: a 5-1 defeat at Dunfermline, a 1-1 home draw with Livingston, and a 3-2 loss at Partick Thistle last time out. The two clean sheets are real, but they are now a month old.
Ayr have no such pattern because they have conceded in every one of their last five. At home they have been lively, beating Queen's Park 3-2 and Raith Rovers 3-1, though they also lost 1-0 to Partick Thistle and drew 1-1 with Dunfermline. The only one of those five played away from home was at Arbroath, and it ended in a 4-1 defeat. That is a single match and no basis for grand claims about their travelling, but it is the most recent evidence of Ayr on the road, and it was not pretty.
The clubs both sides have played
Arbroath, Dunfermline, Partick Thistle and Raith Rovers have faced both. Against that group Inverness won two and lost two, scoring seven and conceding eight. Ayr won one, drew one and lost two, scoring five and conceding seven.
- Arbroath: Inverness won 2-0 at home; Ayr lost 4-1 away.
- Dunfermline: Ayr drew 1-1 at home; Inverness lost 5-1 away.
- Partick Thistle: Inverness lost 3-2 away; Ayr lost 1-0 at home.
- Raith Rovers: Inverness won 2-0 away; Ayr won 3-1 at home.
The Arbroath and Dunfermline results point in opposite directions, and home and away muddle each comparison. If anything tips it, it is that Inverness won at Raith and narrowly lost at Partick, while Ayr did their best work against this group at home.
The one previous meeting
The sides met on 12 September and Inverness won 3-1 at Ayr. One game, two months ago, is not a pattern. But it was an away win by two goals, and Inverness now have home advantage for the return.
Verdict
I lean towards Inverness. They are at home, they won the September meeting comfortably, they beat Arbroath where Ayr were beaten heavily, and they have at least shown they can keep a clean sheet this autumn, which is more than Ayr have done across their last five. Goals at both ends look more likely than not, given that Inverness have conceded in each of their last three and Ayr have conceded in all five.
What would change my mind is the Inverness defence. If the side that shipped five at Dunfermline turns up rather than the one that kept out Arbroath and Raith, Ayr have been scoring freely enough lately to punish it, and their draw with Dunfermline suggests they can hold their own against decent opposition. On balance, though, the home side have the better case.