News › Queen's Park

Queen's Park's hunt for a goal meets Livingston's defence

Queen's Park have lost five in a row and scored in only one of them. Livingston arrive with four clean sheets in five. Form, common opponents and a verdict.

By Barrie Moran,

One line in Queen's Park's recent record explains most of their bother. Their only two goals in five matches came on 31 October at Ayr United, and they still lost 3-2. Take that afternoon away and they have gone four matches without scoring, losing every one. Saturday's visitors to Lesser Hampden are Livingston, who have kept four clean sheets in their last five. That is not a kind meeting of trends for the home side.

Queen's Park's run of defeats

The sequence reads L L L L L, with two goals scored and nine conceded. Look at the scorelines one by one, though, and they have not been taken apart. Stenhousemuir beat them 2-0. Partick Thistle won 1-0 at Lesser Hampden. Ayr won 3-2. Dunfermline won 1-0 on the same ground. Greenock Morton won 2-0. None of those defeats was by more than two goals, and two came by a single goal at home.

The trouble is at the other end. A side that loses 1-0 once is a goal away from a point. A side that keeps losing 1-0 has a problem putting the ball in the net, and that is what this run shows.

Livingston's defensive record

Livingston are unbeaten in five, W D W W D, with seven scored and one conceded. That one goal came in the 1-1 draw at Inverness. Every other match was a shut-out: 0-0 at Dunfermline, 1-0 against Arbroath, 3-0 at Stenhousemuir and 2-0 against Greenock Morton last weekend.

They are not running up cricket scores, mind. Apart from the 3-0 at Stenhousemuir, their wins have been by one and two goals, and there is a goalless draw in there too. This is a side that wins by being very hard to score against.

The common opponents

Both clubs have played Dunfermline, Greenock Morton and Stenhousemuir in this run, and the contrast is stark. Queen's Park lost all three without scoring and conceded five. Livingston took two wins and a draw from the same three fixtures, scoring five and conceding none.

Stenhousemuir is the sharpest comparison. Livingston won 3-0 there on 30 October, and Queen's Park lost 2-0 on the same ground on 14 November. Dunfermline is the nearest thing to common ground: a 1-0 home defeat for Queen's Park against a goalless draw away for Livingston.

The last meeting

The most recent meeting was on 1 August, when Livingston won 2-0 at home. It fits the pattern, but it is one match, at the other ground, nearly four months ago. I would not lean on it.

Verdict

Livingston to win. Every strand points the same way, and the clearest is a defence that has conceded once in five meeting an attack that has scored in only one of its last five. I would expect it to be close rather than comfortable, though. Queen's Park have kept their defeats narrow, and Livingston rarely run away with matches.

Five matches is a small sample, and the margins in Queen's Park's run are thin enough that one goal changes the picture. If they score first, I would think again. Until they show they can find the net against a side like this, the record is Livingston's.

Latest Queen's Park news