PLZ Soccer › Watch › The Journos › The Journos Archive
The Journos · 9 September 2026
A football stats-dominated debate on a huge weekend in Scottish football. The panel react to the news that Rangers captain Lawrence Shankland faces up to four months out with a hamstring tear, ask who now leads and scores the goals for Derek McInnes, and get stuck into a fiery argument about whether football's obsession with data and set-piece coaches is genius or "a complete bluff". Plus Celtic's transfer dysfunction, the Old Firm and cup-weekend predictions, and the three managers whose jobs could be on the line.
HOW BAD IS THE SHANKLAND INJURY FOR RANGERS?
The panel say Shankland's hamstring tear, which could keep him out for around four months, is a hammer blow for Derek McInnes, costing Rangers their captain and main goal threat just as he found form. With Youssef Chermiti also injured, they question whether Ryan Naderi, Kevin Kelsy or new signing Bouanani can score the goals, and who now provides leadership in the biggest games.
IS FOOTBALL'S DATA OBSESSION A CON?
In the episode's fieriest exchange, Gordon Parks argues that much of modern football analytics and the rise of set-piece coaches is "a complete bluff" and "the emperor's new clothes", while Peter Martin and Graeme McGarry make the case that data and specialists like set-piece coaches deliver the small margins that win games. They debate Jamestown Analytics, Arne Engels' 22 million pound move to West Ham, and why managers who have played the game still trust the eye test.
WHICH MANAGERS ARE UNDER PRESSURE THIS WEEKEND?
With three managers under real pressure across the cup ties, the panel argue Stephen Robinson has never been accepted by Aberdeen fans, that David Gray is nearing the end at Hibs with apathy setting in at Easter Road, and preview Ross County v Hibs, Kilmarnock v Aberdeen and Stenhousemuir v Hearts, where Marvin Bartley's unbeaten side aim to cause a shock.
WHO ARE THE BEST SUMMER SIGNINGS IN SCOTLAND?
The panel run through a data-driven ranking of the ten best permanent summer signings, led by Hearts' Josh McPake, and give their Ballon d'Or verdicts on Harry Kane, Kylian Mbappe and Erling Haaland.
The Journos Highlights:
00:00 Intro + the Hummel team-kit deal
01:49 Shankland faces FOUR MONTHS out: a hammer blow for Rangers
04:09 Rangers' striker crisis: who scores the goals?
05:27 Who leads Rangers without Shankland? The Raskin question
09:56 Raskin vs Engels and Celtic's £22m sale
11:18 Data vs the eye test: 'managers know players'
16:06 Set-piece coaches: competitive edge or 'a complete bluff'?
23:55 Playing out from the back: brave or stupid?
25:22 The Lewis Ferguson-to-Rangers story
27:33 Celtic's transfer dysfunction and lost European ambition
31:51 Old Firm prediction: who wins at Ibrox?
32:54 Cup weekend: three managers on the brink
33:30 Why Aberdeen fans turned on Stephen Robinson
38:59 David Gray: 'I can smell the end' at Hibs
41:12 Stenhousemuir v Hearts: can Bartley's men shock them?
43:10 The 10 best summer signings: the data feature
48:12 Ballon d'Or 2026: Kane, Mbappe or Haaland?
Need a new kit for your team? Get 10% off Hummel teamwear: https://www.teamkits.com/ (code PLZSOCCER10)
Subscribe and join the football family for honest, no-spin Scottish football every day.
Play PLZ Predictor - win a car or £10,000: https://bit.ly/plzpredictor
#TheJournos #ScottishFootball #SPFL #Celtic #Rangers #PLZSoccer
PLZ Predictor · Scottish league tables · Scottish football news