PLZ Soccer › Watch › The Journos › The Journos Archive

Should Martin O'Neill STAY at Celtic? The Journos debate the manager Celtic dilemma

The Journos · 20 May 2026

Watch on YouTube

Martin O'Neill has dragged Celtic over the title line and is preparing for a Cup Final double. So — does he get the Celtic job permanently, or do Celtic rebuild around someone like Jens Berthel Askou?

Peter Martin, Hugh McDonald and Gordon Parks weigh both sides:

"What a SHINING POLISH he's put on it. There's your remarkable story." — Hugh on O'Neill's legacy
"He turned round to Saracchi and gave him a cuddle. In one moment he signified to everybody — I'm not forgetting anybody, the contribution." — Peter on the dressing-room moment
"Martin O'Neill's ran his race. But Celtic's problems are far greater than that. The whole structure of the club has to be looked at." — Gordon delivers the verdict

YOU decide — does Martin O'Neill stay or do Celtic rebuild?

⏱ CHAPTERS

00:00:00 Welcome to The Journos
00:00:56 Steve Clarke's 26-man Scotland World Cup squad announced
00:03:00 Squad culture, camaraderie & Gordon Strachan's loyalty blueprint
00:04:00 Craig Brown's Scotland U16 World Cup Final spirit
00:06:19 Liam Kelly & Rangers dressing-room culture
00:07:00 Why Scotland have under-performed at recent tournaments
00:09:00 Derek McInnes & the international-manager career arc
00:14:00 Hearts' season — Craig Halkett and the steadfast players
00:17:30 Why Hearts looked tired in the title-decider
00:22:14 Is Martin O'Neill still embraced? The man-manager qualities
00:26:01 The dressing-room moment — O'Neill's cuddle for Saracchi
00:27:55 "What a SHINING POLISH he's put on it" — praise for Martin O'Neill
00:28:15 "Martin O'Neill's ran his race" — Gordon delivers the verdict
00:29:30 Jens Berthel Askou as the forward-thinking Celtic pick
00:30:12 Celtic's next chairman question
00:31:00 Scottish clubs aren't unearthing players any more
00:33:00 No ambition in Europe — Celtic's credibility crisis
00:36:00 What Celtic should do over the summer
00:38:18 "Pitch invasion is a bad look" — Steve Clarke's response
00:40:00 Is over-exuberance breaking the law? Policing the moment
00:41:00 When pitch invasions cross the line
00:45:00 Saturday's title-decider — winner-take-all psychology
00:46:42 Pitch invasion, sectarian abuse & player attacks
00:48:07 Scottish Cup Final — Celtic vs Dunfermline preview
00:48:30 Statue-daft? The Martin O'Neill statue question
00:50:50 Pupil vs master — never bet against Neil Lennon
00:55:00 Arsenal finally win the Premier League — long overdue
00:55:18 Can Arsenal win the Champions League? Probably not
00:55:35 Terry Christian, Man United & the Fergie legacy
00:56:16 Fergie's Aberdeen — taken to another planet
00:57:00 Mourinho at Porto & Inter Milan's Champions League win
00:58:54 Spygate appeal — where is football going?
01:00:08 East Ireland & Dennis Newell's corner routine (banter)
01:01:00 Next week — the definitive 50 best Scottish Premier players since 1975
01:02:00 Scotland & the World Cup countdown

🔔 SUBSCRIBE for more from PLZ Soccer: https://www.youtube.com/@PLZSoccer?sub_confirmation=1

🎙️ Listen to The Journos podcast wherever you get your podcasts.

🚐 The Journos is sponsored by Cameron Commercial Vehicles. For quality new and used vans, visit https://CameronCommercials.com

martin o'neill, martin o'neill celtic, martin o'neill celtic manager, is martin o'neill too old, should martin o'neill stay, will martin o'neill stay or leave, martin o'neill stay, martin o'neill leave celtic, celtic manager debate, celtic next manager, celtic next manager debate, celtic interim manager, celtic manager dilemma, celtic 2026, celtic champions, celtic fc, brendan rodgers, saracchi, marcelo saracchi, saracchi celtic, jens berthel askou, jens berthel askou celtic, motherwell, callum mcgregor, daizen maeda, arne engels, callum osmand, james forrest, iheanacho, scottish football, spfl, scottish premiership, scottish cup final, celtic vs dunfermline, plz soccer, the journos, the football show, celtic dunfermline, neil lennon, celtic park, hampden, dermot desmond, steve clarke, scotland world cup squad, ross stewart, findlay curtis, peter martin, hugh mcdonald, gordon parks, o'neill celtic legacy, celtic interim hero

#MartinONeill #CelticFC #ScottishFootball

Clubs in this video

More from The Journos Archive

PLZ Predictor · Scottish league tables · Scottish football news