Annan's Dumbarton rout meets a Forfar side without a clean sheet
Annan Athletic host Forfar Athletic at Galabank after a 5-0 win that followed four defeats. Barrie Moran looks at the form, the common opponents and the only recent meeting.
By Barrie Moran,
Last Saturday Annan Athletic went to Dumbarton and won 5-0. That result will be quoted all week before Forfar Athletic come to Galabank, and it deserves quoting. It also sits on top of four straight defeats, the worst of them a 6-1 home hammering by Stranraer on 10 October. One month Annan could not stop conceding. Last week they scored five and kept a clean sheet away from home. Which of those sides turns up on Saturday decides this game.
Annan Athletic's recent form
Across the last five Annan have scored ten and conceded fifteen, with one win, four defeats and one clean sheet. Five of those goals and the only clean sheet came at Dumbarton. The run that came before it is worth reading in order, though: 6-1 at home to Stranraer, 4-1 at Clyde, 3-2 at Spartans, 2-1 at home to Kelty Hearts. Each defeat was closer than the one before. On that reading the Dumbarton win was the end of a slow climb rather than a bolt from nowhere.
Annan have also scored in every one of those five matches. The worry is at home, where their last two outings at Galabank ended in that Stranraer defeat and the narrow loss to Kelty Hearts.
Forfar Athletic's recent form
Forfar's last five read one win, one draw, three defeats, seven scored and eleven conceded. They have not kept a clean sheet in any of them. Their run has improved as well, if less dramatically. A 2-1 home defeat by Elgin City, a 2-1 loss at Kelty Hearts and a 5-2 beating at Stirling Albion were followed by a 1-1 draw with Edinburgh City and a 2-1 home win over Spartans.
The away results are the ones that matter here, and they are not encouraging. They lost at Kelty and conceded five at Stirling.
Common opponents and the last meeting
Both sides have played Kelty Hearts and Spartans. Annan lost to both by a single goal, scoring three and conceding five. Forfar beat Spartans 2-1 at home and lost 2-1 at Kelty, scoring three and conceding three. That is a slight edge to Forfar, built on two matches.
The most recent meeting also went Forfar's way: a 1-0 win at home on 19 September. One goal in one game two months ago is a thin basis for anything. It does show that Forfar have already found a way past Annan this season, and that Annan failed to score that day. They have scored in every game since the start of October.
Verdict
The head-to-head and the common opponents both point gently towards Forfar, and I would not dismiss either. Recent form points the other way, and recent form is where I land. Annan's defeats were getting narrower before Dumbarton, they have scored in each of their last five, and Forfar have not kept a clean sheet in any of theirs. I expect goals at both ends and lean towards Annan edging it at Galabank.
If I am wrong it will be because Dumbarton was a one-off, and the side that lost at home to Stranraer and Kelty is the real one. In that case the September result is the better guide, and Forfar's improving run is enough to win it.