Arbroath and Stenhousemuir arrive with identical form lines
Both sides read W L L L L going into Gayfield. Barrie Moran looks at which recent win means more, and leans narrowly one way.
By Barrie Moran,
Put the last five results of Arbroath and Stenhousemuir side by side and you could swap the badges without anyone noticing. Both read W L L L L. Both have won one and lost four. Both have scored five. Arbroath have let in 10, Stenhousemuir 11. And both come into Saturday's Championship meeting at Gayfield off the back of their only win in that run.
So the question is not who is in better form. Neither is. It is which of those recent wins tells you more.
Arbroath's one big afternoon
Arbroath's 4-1 win over Ayr United on 7 November is the result that flatters their form line. Look at the rest. They lost 4-0 at home to Raith Rovers, 1-0 at Livingston, 2-0 at Inverness and 2-1 at home to Greenock Morton. They failed to score against Raith, Livingston and Inverness, and managed one against Morton. That is a side that found its shooting boots for one game in five. It is too early to say whether the Ayr result was a corner turned or simply a day when everything went in.
Stenhousemuir's clean sheet stands out
Stenhousemuir's run carries the one detail neither side can match elsewhere. Their 2-0 win over Queen's Park on 14 November is the only clean sheet either club has kept in their last five. Before that, they lost 3-0 at Partick Thistle, 1-0 at home to Dunfermline and 3-0 at home to Livingston without scoring in any of them. Then came an odd 4-3 defeat at Morton, where they scored three and still came away with nothing. Goals at one end, none at the other, then the reverse. It has not been a settled spell.
Common opponents favour Arbroath
Both sides have played Livingston and Morton recently, and both lost both. The manner differs. Arbroath scored 1 and conceded 3 across those two games, losing each by a single goal. Stenhousemuir scored 3 but conceded 7. Livingston won 1-0 at Arbroath's expense away from home, and beat Stenhousemuir 3-0 on Stenhousemuir's own ground. Morton edged Arbroath at Gayfield and needed four to see off Stenhousemuir at home.
It is a small sample, two games each, but it is the closest thing to a like-for-like comparison available, and it points to Arbroath being the harder side to beat when the opposition is the same.
The only recent meeting
The sides met on 19 September, Stenhousemuir winning 1-0 at home. One match, one goal, two months ago. It tells you this can be tight. It does not tell you much else, and I would not lean on it too heavily in either direction.
Verdict
I lean towards Arbroath, narrowly. Against common opponents they have kept the margins small, and their one emphatic result of the autumn came at Gayfield. But the 4-0 home defeat by Raith is a reminder that home has been no fortress, and the September meeting went Stenhousemuir's way.
What would change my mind is the Queen's Park result. If that clean sheet marks Stenhousemuir tightening up rather than a one-off, then goals Arbroath have struggled to find in four of their last five will be harder still to come by, and the visitors' habit of conceding heavily stops being the weakness I am counting on. A home win is my view, held without much confidence, and a draw between two sides this evenly matched in their troubles would surprise nobody.