Hibernian host unbeaten Dundee United after Aberdeen win
Hibernian's 4-0 win at Aberdeen meets Dundee United's five-game unbeaten run at Easter Road, with the October meeting and PLZ Predictor picks.
By Harvey Watkins,
The most recent result is the one that complicates this fixture. Hibernian went to Aberdeen on 7 November and won 4-0, their only victory in five matches and easily their most convincing. Dundee United arrive at Easter Road unbeaten in that same stretch. Read the form tables alone and United look the clear side in better shape. Read the latest scoreline and the picture is less settled.
Hibernian's form
Before the trip to Aberdeen, Hibernian had gone four league matches without a win: a 1-0 defeat at Dundee United, then 2-1 losses at home to Falkirk and Celtic, then a 1-1 draw at St. Mirren. That run reads W D L L L, and they have scored seven and conceded six across the five games.
Home form is the concern. Both of their matches at Easter Road in this run ended in 2-1 defeats. Losing narrowly to Celtic is no great disgrace, but the Falkirk result is harder to explain away. The 4-0 at Aberdeen was also their only clean sheet in the five, so one emphatic away win sits against a broader pattern of narrow margins going the wrong way.
Dundee United's form
United's sequence is D D W D W: two wins, three draws, no defeats, eight goals scored and six conceded. Draws have been the theme. They drew 1-1 at St. Johnstone and 1-1 at home to Motherwell, but they also came away from Celtic with a 2-2, which is the result in their run that stands out most.
Their attacking returns are steady rather than spectacular, and they have kept one clean sheet in five. That clean sheet came in the 1-0 win over Hibernian.
Common opponents
Both sides have played Aberdeen and Celtic in recent weeks. Hibernian won 4-0 at Aberdeen and lost 2-1 at home to Celtic, for five scored and two conceded. United beat Aberdeen 3-2 at home and drew 2-2 at Celtic, scoring five and conceding four. Hibernian have the better goal difference from those two games, United the better results. It is a small sample either way and points in no firm direction.
The previous meeting
The only recent meeting was on 10 October, when Dundee United won 1-0 at home. That is one match, played at the other ground, and it says little on its own. It does show that Hibernian found United hard to break down six weeks ago.
What PLZ members think
Five PLZ Soccer members have entered this fixture in the PLZ Predictor. Sixty per cent have gone for a draw and 40 per cent for an away win, with none backing Hibernian. The most popular scoreline is 2-2, picked by two members. With so few entries, it is a snapshot of opinion rather than anything more.
The assessment
United's run gives them a reasonable case, and they have already beaten Hibernian once this autumn. Against that, Hibernian's win at Aberdeen was their strongest showing of the period, and they will hope it marks a turn rather than an exception. My view is that a close game is likelier than a comfortable one, with United's habit of drawing making a share of the points a plausible outcome. A repeat of the Aberdeen performance from Hibernian would change that quickly, and a third straight home defeat is just as possible.