News › Kilmarnock

Kilmarnock and Aberdeen meet with little form to lean on

Harvey Watkins looks at recent results, shared opponents, September's goalless meeting and what PLZ Predictor members expect at Rugby Park.

By Harvey Watkins,

Neither side arrives at Rugby Park with much to recommend its recent form. Kilmarnock have won one of their last five, Aberdeen one of theirs, and neither has kept a clean sheet in that run. The margins between them look narrow, and the last meeting, a goalless draw in September, hints that they may stay that way.

Kilmarnock's recent results

Kilmarnock's sequence reads L D L L W, with six goals scored and 11 conceded. The win came on 17 October, a 3-2 home victory over Motherwell. Two heavy defeats on the road followed, 3-0 at Falkirk and 3-1 at Dundee FC. A 2-2 home draw with St. Johnstone steadied things before a 1-0 loss at Celtic on 8 November.

That last result is arguably the most encouraging in the run. Conceding once at Celtic is a tighter showing than the three-goal defeats before it, although it came without a goal at the other end. At home in this spell, Kilmarnock scored three against Motherwell and two against St. Johnstone. Finding the net at Rugby Park has not been the difficulty. Keeping goals out has.

Aberdeen's recent results

Aberdeen's sequence is L L L W L, with five scored and ten conceded. The win was a convincing one, 3-1 against St. Mirren on 17 October, but the results around it are harder reading. They lost 1-0 at home to St. Johnstone, 3-2 at Dundee United, 1-0 at home to Falkirk and then 4-0 at home to Hibernian on 7 November.

The scoring is the concern. Against St. Johnstone, Falkirk and Hibernian they did not score at all. The St. Mirren win and the defeat at Dundee United show goals are possible, but they have not come consistently, and the Hibernian result is the heaviest defeat either side has taken in this run.

Shared opponents

Both clubs have played Falkirk and St. Johnstone recently. Kilmarnock took a draw from those two games, scoring two and conceding five. Aberdeen lost both, scoring none and conceding two.

That comparison can be read either way. Aberdeen were the tighter side in those fixtures, losing each by a single goal, while Kilmarnock were more open but also carried more threat. Two matches apiece is a thin basis for judgement, though, and it should not carry too much weight.

The September meeting

The most recent meeting ended Aberdeen 0-0 Kilmarnock on 5 September. A single game is not a pattern, and both sides' form has moved on since, but it is a reminder that this fixture has already produced one cautious, low-scoring afternoon this season.

What PLZ Predictor members expect

Five PLZ Soccer members have entered this fixture in the PLZ Predictor. Of those, 40 per cent expect a draw, 40 per cent an Aberdeen win and 20 per cent a Kilmarnock win. The most common scoreline is 1-1, picked by two members. With so few entries this is a snapshot of opinion among our members rather than any kind of forecast.

Assessment

There is little to separate these sides on form. Kilmarnock have at least been scoring at home, and Aberdeen have been conceding regularly, which points slightly towards the home side. Against that, Kilmarnock have not kept a clean sheet in five, and Aberdeen have shown against St. Mirren that they can still put a side away.

My view is that Kilmarnock have a modest edge, with a draw very much in play. Neither defence has given much reason for confidence lately, so a repeat of September's goalless draw looks less likely than it did then. Either result, or an Aberdeen win, would sit comfortably within what recent weeks have shown.

Latest Kilmarnock news