Peterhead's Balmoor form faces free-scoring East Kilbride
Form, the shared opponents and the September meeting, plus why the venue matters more than usual when Peterhead host East Kilbride in League One.
By Barrie Moran,
Peterhead's last five makes grim reading: three defeats, five scored and nine conceded. Look at where those games were played, though, and the picture changes. Both wins came at Balmoor, 2-0 against Cove Rangers on 17 October and 2-1 against Alloa Athletic on 31 October. All three defeats came on the road: 3-0 at Montrose, 4-1 at Ross County and 1-0 at East Fife last Saturday. That split is the detail this fixture turns on, because Saturday's game is at Balmoor.
Two different Peterheads
At home, Peterhead have scored twice in each of their recent matches and kept their only clean sheet of the run against Cove Rangers. Away, they failed to score at Montrose and East Fife and shipped four at Ross County. The 1-0 at East Fife was the tightest of the away defeats, but a defeat it still was. The home record comes from two matches, so it is not much to build on. It is still the best case Peterhead have.
East Kilbride arrive in good touch
East Kilbride have won their last two, 4-1 at home to Alloa Athletic and 2-1 at Queen of the South, and before that drew with Montrose and Airdrieonians either side of a 2-1 home defeat to Ross County. Ten scored and seven conceded across the five, and they have scored in every one of those matches. They have not kept a clean sheet in that run, which matters given what Peterhead manage at home.
Four of those five games were at home. Their only recent away fixture, at Queen of the South, ended in a win. That is encouraging for them, but it is one result.
The shared opponents, read carefully
Both sides have played Alloa Athletic, Montrose and Ross County. East Kilbride took a win, a draw and a defeat with six scored and four conceded. Peterhead took a win and two defeats, scoring three and conceding eight. That looks lopsided until you check the venues. East Kilbride played all three at home. Peterhead played two of them away.
The like-for-like comparison is Alloa at home, where Peterhead won 2-1 and East Kilbride won 4-1. East Kilbride still come out ahead, but the gap is narrower than the headline figures suggest.
The September meeting
The most recent meeting went East Kilbride's way, 3-1 at their place on 12 September. It counts for something, but it is one game, played at the other end of the fixture.
Verdict
East Kilbride are the better side on current form. They score more and they have been beaten less often. But Balmoor has been where Peterhead play their best football this autumn, and that narrows the gap. I expect a close game with goals at both ends, since East Kilbride have not kept a clean sheet in five and Peterhead have scored freely at home. If I have to lean, I lean East Kilbride, though not by much.
A draw would not surprise me, and a Peterhead win would not count as an upset given their home results. What would change my mind is East Kilbride showing they can control a game away from home. Until then, their record on the road is too short to trust fully.