News › Elgin City

Stranraer's shut door meets an Elgin City side short of goals

Stranraer have conceded once in five and hammered Elgin City in September. Barrie Moran weighs the form, the shared opponents and where Elgin might find a way in.

By Barrie Moran,

If you want one line that explains Stranraer at the moment, it is this: the only goal they have let in over their last five matches came in a game they won 6-1. Four clean sheets in five, one goal against, and that one arrived at Annan when the afternoon was long since settled. Elgin City come to Stair Park needing to find a way through a door that has been bolted for over a month.

Stranraer's run since early October

The sequence reads W W D W W, with 12 scored and 1 conceded. The 6-1 at Annan Athletic on 10 October is the eye-catching result, but the more telling stretch is what followed. A 2-0 win at Spartans, a goalless draw with Clyde, a 3-0 home win over Stirling Albion, and last week a 1-0 at Kelty Hearts. That is a side that has won in different ways: by a landslide, comfortably, and narrowly.

The one blemish is the 0-0 with Clyde, and it came at Stair Park. It is worth noting only because it shows Stranraer can be held when they do not score early. It is not much of a crack.

Elgin City's mixed month

Elgin's last five run L L W D W, with 4 scored and 5 conceded. They started this spell well enough, winning 2-1 at Forfar Athletic, drawing 0-0 with Edinburgh City and winning 1-0 at Kelty Hearts. Then it turned. Dumbarton won 2-0 in Elgin on 7 November, and last week Stirling Albion beat them 2-1.

The goals are the issue. Only once in those five matches did Elgin score more than one, and against a defence like Stranraer's that is a thin margin to work with. In fairness, they have two clean sheets of their own in that run, so they are capable of making a match tight.

The clubs both sides have played

Kelty Hearts and Stirling Albion have faced both teams recently, and the comparison does Elgin few favours. Both sides won 1-0 at Kelty, so there is nothing between them there. Stirling Albion is where it splits: Stranraer beat them 3-0, while Elgin lost 2-1 to them a week later. Across those two opponents Stranraer scored 4 and conceded 0; Elgin scored 2 and conceded 2.

Two matches is a small sample, and I would not lean on it too hard. But it points the same way as everything else.

The September meeting

The most recent meeting was on 19 September, and it was emphatic: Elgin City 1-5 Stranraer, in Elgin. That was two months ago and form moves on, but Stranraer won by four goals away from home, and they look a tighter side now than their opponents do.

The verdict

Stranraer are the side to back here, in the plain sense of my view rather than anything else. They are at home, they are barely conceding, they won the last meeting by four goals and they beat the one shared opponent Elgin lost to. I expect a home win.

What would change my mind is if Elgin can reproduce the version of themselves that kept clean sheets against Edinburgh City and Kelty Hearts. If they keep it level and make it a slow, tight afternoon, the Clyde draw shows Stranraer can be frustrated at home. But Elgin have to score to win, and over the last month that has been the hardest thing they do, against a side that has made it very hard for anyone.

Latest Elgin City news