PLZ Soccer › Watch › The Journos › The Journos Archive
The Journos · 1 May 2025
Peter Martin is joined by Alison McConnell, Hugh MacDonald and Andrew Smith for a heated debate on SFA's new gender policy, SPFL league reconstruction, Arne Engels Young Player of the Year nomination and much more!
Get EXCLUSIVE members only content: https://www.youtube.com/@PLZSoccer/join
SUBSCRIBE NOW: https://youtube.com/@PLZSoccer?sub_confirmation=1
Join host Peter Martin alongside Hugh MacDonald, Andrew Smith, and Alison McConnell as they tackle the biggest and most controversial issues in Scottish football.
⚖️ SFA Gender Policy Update:
Reaction to the SFA's new policy following the Supreme Court ruling, defining gender participation in domestic football based on biological sex from 2025/26.
⚠️ Protecting Women’s Sport:
Panel debate on the physical and physiological implications of transgender inclusion in women’s football and the social, legal, and ethical layers involved.
🏆 SPFL League Reconstruction:
Heated discussion on possible structural changes in the top four divisions and whether 42 professional clubs is sustainable.
🧠 B-Team Partnerships & Youth Development:
Insights into Celtic scrapping their B team and partnering with Championship clubs, including dual registrations and development models.
🎖️ PFA Scotland Awards Preview:
Who deserves Manager, Player, and Young Player of the Year? The panel discuss Maeda, Engstler, Lennon Miller, and more.
🧱 Scottish Football’s Power Struggles:
Examination of the SPFL voting system, club self-interest, and whether real change is possible under the current governance.
💼 Rangers’ New Ownership & Manager Search:
The panel assess investor PR, the sporting director's influence, and whether names like Sean Dyche and Steven Gerrard are realistic fits.
🌍 Champions League Magic:
A look back at thrilling recent matches, breakout young talents like Lamine Yamal, and their picks for all-time most dramatic Champions League games.
00:00:00 – Intro
00:00:36 – SFA Ruling on Gender and Sport
Discussion on the SFA’s new gender participation policy following the Supreme Court ruling. Hugh, Alison, Andrew, and Peter examine implications for women’s sport and transgender athletes.
00:11:50 – SPFL League Reconstruction Debate
Peter introduces Steven McGowan’s reporting on potential league changes. Panel debates viability of restructuring Scottish leagues, from Premiership to League Two.
00:15:00 – The 42-Team Structure and Club Sustainability
Andrew questions if Scotland can sustain 42 clubs. Hugh and Alison debate meritocracy, ambition, and financial fairness.
00:20:06 – The Pyramid System and Promotion Issues
Critique of promotion between Highland/Lowland leagues and League Two. Examples include Clydebank and Spartans.
00:23:31 – Celtic’s B Team and Championship Partnerships
Andrew reveals a Celtic Underground exclusive about B teams being replaced by Premiership-Championship loan partnerships.
00:26:02 – Expanded League and Four Old Firm Games
Peter and Hugh push for more top-flight teams despite media pressure to retain four Old Firm derbies.
00:29:04 – SPFL Voting Structure and Financial Imbalance
The group explores the league’s voting structure, revenue gaps, and the challenges to meaningful change.
00:34:06 – PFA Scotland Awards 2025: Manager of the Year
Debate over whether Brendan Rodgers, John McGlynn, or David Gray deserves Manager of the Year.
00:35:46 – Player of the Year: Daizen Maeda vs. Simon Murray
Arguments for and against Daizen Maeda and Simon Murray for Player of the Year.
00:38:45 – Young Player of the Year: Arne Engels, Wilson, Lennon Miller
Alison, Hugh, and Andrew weigh up Arne Engels, James Wilson, and Lennon Miller. Peter doubts Engel's impact.
00:42:55 – Player Judgement Based on Performances vs. Price Tags
Engel’s role at Celtic compared to expectations and his actual contribution.
00:47:02 – Rangers Takeover and New Investors
Analysis of potential new Rangers owners/investors. Discussion on PR efforts, board strategy, and stadium presentation.
00:50:06 – Sean Dyche as Potential Rangers Manager?
Panel assesses Dyche's suitability. Hugh and Andrew highlight his strengths as a team builder and pragmatic coach.
00:54:55 – Champions League: Barcelona vs Inter Milan Review
Panel reacts to exciting match. Praise for young talent like Lamine Yamal and resurgence in Champions League quality.
00:59:38 – Best Champions League Games for Drama
Peter and team list their favourite dramatic UCL matches (e.g., Liverpool 4–0 Barcelona, Spurs vs Ajax, Ronaldo at Old Trafford).
More to Watch:
Ian Durrant on his bust-up with Graeme Souness: https://youtu.be/XI7dE1ooR5c
Martin O'Neill on his time at Celtic: https://youtu.be/in25WpJJnI0
David Martindale behind the scenes at Livingston: https://youtu.be/6yI6psxcfGE
VISIT PLZ SOCCER HERE:
SUBSCRIBE: https://www.youtube.com/c/plzsoccer?sub_confirmation=1
FACEBOOK: https://Facebook.com/plzsoccer
X: https://twitter.com/plzsoccer
WEBSITE: https://www.plzsoccer.com
PLZ Predictor · Scottish league tables · Scottish football news