Dumbarton's September win sits awkwardly with their recent form
Spartans host Dumbarton at Ainslie Park, where three shared opponents tell a different story from the 3-0 the Sons won in September.
By Barrie Moran,
When Dumbarton beat Spartans 3-0 on 19 September, it looked like a statement. Two months on it looks more like the high point of a run that has gone badly wrong for the Sons, and the clearest evidence comes from three clubs both sides have faced since.
Three shared opponents, two very different stories
Annan Athletic, Clyde and Edinburgh City have all played both of Saturday's sides. Spartans took two wins and a defeat from those matches, scoring eight and conceding six. Dumbarton lost all three, scoring two and conceding nine.
The Annan results are the sharpest contrast. Spartans beat them 3-2 at Ainslie Park on 31 October. A fortnight later Annan went to Dumbarton and won 5-0. Against Edinburgh City, Spartans won 3-1 away on 10 October, while Dumbarton lost 2-1 there three weeks later. Clyde beat both, 3-2 against Spartans and 2-1 against Dumbarton, so that one tells you little.
Three matches is not much to build on, and no side is the same opponent every week. But when the comparison points the same way each time, it is worth taking seriously.
Spartans: goals at both ends
Spartans' last five read L L W L W, with nine scored, ten conceded and no clean sheet. This is not a side that keeps games tidy. They have put three past Annan and Edinburgh City, yet their two most recent outings were one-goal defeats, 3-2 at Clyde and 2-1 at Forfar Athletic.
The worrying one is closer to home. Stranraer came to Ainslie Park on 17 October and won 2-0, the only match of the five in which Spartans failed to score. Their home form is not a fortress, and the defensive record suggests Dumbarton will get chances.
Dumbarton: one good afternoon
Dumbarton's sequence is L W L D L, with five scored and ten conceded. The 2-0 win at Elgin City on 7 November stands alone as their only win and their only clean sheet in that spell. Around it sit a 2-1 defeat at Clyde, a 1-1 draw at home to Stirling Albion and a 2-1 loss at Edinburgh City.
Then came last Saturday. Losing 5-0 at home is bad enough. Losing 5-0 at home to a side Spartans had beaten a fortnight earlier is the detail that frames this fixture. If the Elgin result showed what Dumbarton can be, the Annan one showed how far off it they can fall.
The September meeting
The one recent meeting went entirely Dumbarton's way, 3-0 at their place. That should not be dismissed. It is the only direct evidence of how these two sides match up, and it was emphatic. But it is a single game, played before either side's current run began, and everything since has pointed the other way.
The verdict
I lean towards Spartans. Their form is patchy and their defence leaks, but they score goals and they have done better against the clubs both sides have played. Dumbarton have scored more than once only in the win at Elgin, and they arrive off the back of a heavy defeat.
What would change my mind is evidence that the Annan result was a freak and the Elgin performance is closer to the real Dumbarton. They have already beaten Spartans comfortably this season, and a side that concedes as freely as Spartans gives any opponent a way back into a game. A Spartans win is my view, not a confident one, and a draw would not surprise me.