News

Edinburgh City v Kelty Hearts: a leaky defence meets a blunt attack

Edinburgh City come off a 6-2 home hammering by Clyde to face a Kelty Hearts side they beat 3-1 in September. Form, shared opponents and a verdict.

By Barrie Moran,

Edinburgh City shipped six at Meadowbank last Saturday. Clyde won 6-2, and it is the result that sits over this fixture. Six of the 11 goals City have conceded in their last five came in that one afternoon. Whether you read the Clyde game as a freak or a warning shapes how you see this match.

Edinburgh City's recent form

City's last five read L D W D L. They have won one, drawn two and lost two, scoring six and conceding 11. Strip out the Clyde game and the picture is steadier. They drew 1-1 at Forfar Athletic, beat Dumbarton 2-1 at home and drew 0-0 at Elgin City, which is their one clean sheet in the run.

The worry is at home. Meadowbank has hosted two of those defeats, 3-1 to Spartans in October and the Clyde result last week. The Dumbarton win is the only home result in the sequence that went their way. A side that is tidy on the road and loose in front of its own support is an odd thing, but that is what the five games show.

Kelty Hearts' recent form

Kelty's sequence is L W L W L: two wins, three defeats, five goals scored and six conceded, with no clean sheets. The defeats have been narrow ones. They lost 1-0 at home to Stranraer last week, 1-0 at home to Elgin City and 2-1 at Stirling Albion. The wins were 2-1 at home to Forfar Athletic and 2-1 at Annan Athletic.

So Kelty are rarely blown away, but they are not keeping the ball out either, and they drew blanks against both Stranraer and Elgin. That is a blunt edge to bring to a ground where the home defence has just been taken apart.

Against the same opponents

Both sides have played Elgin City and Forfar Athletic in this run. City took a draw from each, 1-1 and 0-0, both away from home. Kelty beat Forfar 2-1 and lost 1-0 to Elgin, both at home. City drew both of theirs on the road, while Kelty split theirs on their own pitch, and the two records cancel out more than they separate. It is a sample of two games each, and I would not lean on it.

The previous meeting

The most recent meeting went City's way, and not narrowly. They won 3-1 at Kelty on 19 September. One result is thin evidence, but it is the only direct evidence there is, and it points the same way as the rest.

Verdict

This is a side that concedes against a side that struggles to score. That makes me think the Clyde result says more about Clyde than about City. Kelty have not scored more than twice in any of their last five, and they have been kept out entirely in two of them. City scored in four of their last five, and the only blank was that goalless draw at Elgin.

My view is a narrow Edinburgh City win. I hold it loosely, because their home results this autumn have been poor. If Kelty's road form, a win at Annan and a one-goal defeat at Stirling, proves the truer guide, a draw or an away win would not surprise me. What would change my mind is evidence that last week was not a one-off. Another heavy home defeat would make it a pattern rather than a bad day.

Latest news