Hibernian and Dundee FC meet after heavy defeats last time out
Form, the shared result against St. Mirren, August's meeting and what PLZ Predictor members expect from Tuesday night at Easter Road.
By Harvey Watkins,
Hibernian and Dundee FC arrive at Easter Road on Tuesday evening carrying the same record over their last five matches: one win, one draw, three defeats and seven goals scored. That symmetry does not survive a closer look. The difference between the sides sits at the back, and it is the most useful thing to understand before kick-off.
The defensive gap
Hibernian have conceded nine in their last five and kept one clean sheet. Dundee FC have conceded 15 and kept none. Both lost heavily on 21 November: Hibernian 0-4 at home to Dundee United, Dundee FC 0-8 at home to Hearts. A single result can distort a five-match picture, and the 8-0 accounts for more than half of Dundee's total. Strip it out, though, and the rest of their run still shows a side that has conceded at least once in every game.
Hibernian's one shut-out came in their best performance of the period, a 4-0 win at Aberdeen on 7 November. It is the clearest sign that they can control a match, and also a reminder of how uneven their recent form has been. A fortnight later they lost by the same margin in front of their own supporters.
Easter Road has not been kind
The awkward detail for the home side is where their defeats have come. Each of their home games in this run was lost: 1-2 to Falkirk, 1-2 to Celtic and 0-4 to Dundee United. Their better results, the win at Aberdeen and a 1-1 draw at St. Mirren, both came away. The sample is small and Celtic are a different proposition, but losing narrowly to Falkirk and then heavily to Dundee United does not suggest a side comfortable at home just now.
Dundee FC's mixed returns
Dundee FC's run has more variety than the bare record implies. They drew 2-2 with Rangers on 17 October and beat Kilmarnock 3-1 eleven days later, both at home. Away from home they lost 2-1 at St. Mirren and 2-1 at St. Johnstone, close defeats rather than collapses. Then came the Hearts result. They have scored in every match bar that one, so goals at both ends look a reasonable expectation.
St. Mirren and the August meeting
The only club both sides have faced in this run is St. Mirren. Hibernian drew 1-1 there, Dundee FC lost 2-1. One shared opponent is thin evidence, and the margin is a single goal.
The most recent meeting between these two finished Dundee FC 1-2 Hibernian on 30 August. That is a result in Hibernian's favour, but it was played nearly three months ago and in Dundee, so it says little about how either side is playing now.
What PLZ Predictor members think
Twenty-five PLZ Soccer members have entered predictions for this match in the PLZ Predictor. Of those, 28 per cent have gone for a Hibernian win, 40 per cent for a draw and 32 per cent for a Dundee FC win. The most commonly predicted scoreline is 2-1, chosen by seven members. These are our readers' picks, not odds, and a spread that even mostly shows how open people think the game is.
The view
Hibernian's sturdier defensive record and their win in August make them the slightly more convincing side on paper, and Dundee FC have yet to keep a clean sheet in this run. Against that, Hibernian's home results have been poor and both teams have shown they can score. My view is a narrow home edge in a match likely to see goals for both sides, held loosely given how erratic each has been.