News

Pocognoli should not be sacked yet, says Gordon Parks

Hugh MacDonald and Gordon Parks back the Scotland manager after the 4-0 against Switzerland, while Peter Martin turns to five clubs blocking youth reform.

By Peter Martin,

Sebastien Pocognoli should not lose his job as Scotland manager yet, according to Hugh MacDonald and Gordon Parks on The Football Show. The pair also argued that somebody has to point out the mistakes he has made.

Not yet, but mistakes to answer for

The show opened on whether the SFA should sack Pocognoli after the 4-0 against Switzerland. MacDonald and Parks both said not yet. Parks put it simply: "I don't think they should sack him".

The panel also made the point that "It is harder not to qualify for the Euros".

Backing the manager did not mean ignoring his errors, and the list was specific. It began with Oli McBurnie. It took in wing-backs who let traffic down both flanks, and the decision to drop Kieron Bowie after his first Scotland goal. The final point was Pocognoli not travelling back with the team.

38 Scots out of 132

Peter Martin then turned to the domestic game and a figure that frames the debate about opportunities for home-grown players. Across six Premiership games, he counted 38 Scots out of 132 players.

That led to Craig Mulholland's youth proposals, which five clubs are blocking. The panel summed up the problem in one line: "the needs of the few dominate our game".

The clubs doing it right

Martin did not leave it at criticism. He named three clubs he believes are getting it right: Dundee, Falkirk and Motherwell.

Taken together, the two halves of the show pointed at the same concern. The national team's problems are being debated at the top, and the supply of Scottish players further down is in question too.

Watch the full episode of The Football Show

Latest news